Council Will Consider Banning The Sale Of "Puppy Mill'' Pets

LA MESA - The La Mesa City Council heard for an hour last night from citizens concerned about the sale of puppies raised in so-called puppy mills.

What followed was a short but dogged debate about the role of government in local commerce.

"I hate to see things happening to the cute puppies," said Council Member Ruth Sterling, "then my Republican side comes on and I don't feel so good telling a business owner he can't sell a legal product."

But in the end Mayor Art Madrid, who had just been sworn in for his fifth term earlier in the meeting, said there were precedents for the city to take actions to protect local citizens and he recommended pursuing the issue.

Eventually, the council voted 5-0 to have city staff prepare a study of legislation it could consider to keep puppy mill pets out of local stores.

For several weeks local animal activists have petitioned the council to take action against the Pet Works store in Grossmont Center, which they accused of selling defective and abused pets raised in dirty and unhealthful conditions.

Pet Works denied the allegations but recently announced it was going out of business because of the poor economy.

Animal advocates want local municipalities to require pet stores to sell animals supplied by animal shelters or rescue groups rather than from mass production kennels, often located in the Midwest.

After several emotional speakers, Council Member Sterling read letters from two constituents that told the council to stay out of issues that should be handled by other levels of government or by informed consumers expressing a preference. There was talk of "Big Brother" government and concerns of over-reaching.

Madrid compared the city expressing opposition to puppy mills and defective pets to the city insisting and enforcing its requirement that farmer's market vendors prove that they raise the vegetables they sell.

"We do a number of things to protect the public," Madrid said.

In the end, concern for puppies and their owners, trumped the more libertarian issues and the council agreed to have its staff pursue the issue further. It will be brought up again at a future meeting for the council to consider action.

Sydney Cicourel, leader of the animal advocates at this meeting, expressed optimism with the limited council action.

"I feel elated,'' she said. "Any time they're leaving a door open to something like this."

Views: 42

Tags: Government


You need to be a member of La Mesa Today - Community Website & Online Newspaper to add comments!

Join La Mesa Today - Community Website & Online Newspaper

Comment by Craig S. Maxwell on December 17, 2010 at 2:18pm

"How much of [your] tax money will be squandered on the City Council's feel-good effort" I'll hazard a guess; as much as it takes for them to bank political capital. This is yet another) price we'll pay for for having allowed our mini ship of state to be piloted by by pack unprincipled political hacks.

Comment by joan sullivan on December 17, 2010 at 9:21am

It is the La Mesa City Council's mandate to enact laws which serve the citizens of La Mesa.


Earlier this year a citizen appealed to the City Council for a law which would permit her (and other local Greenies) to keep a few laying hens in her backyard. The City Council rejected her request with the reasonable argument that directing city staff to expend time to investigate the issue and to write and incorporate such a law would cost the city too much tax payer money. No one objected to backyard chickens, just to the cost of creating the ordinance.


I expected a similar response Tuesday night. Instead, the City Council went belly up to a focused, well-organized, well-funded activist group who grabbed the podium and put on a manipulative dog and pony show to serve their goal of shutting down puppy mills in the Mid West.


How much of my tax money will be squandered on the City Council's feel-good effort to shut down puppy mills two thousand miles away by boycotting their product in one little California city? How does this serve the citizens of La Mesa? Puppy mills in Missouri are not germane to the business of running the City of La Mesa.


How many more La Mesa merchants will be run out of town by such activist blackmail threats, "You sell only what I want you to sell or I'll have the pushover City Council write a law to force you."


West Hollywood caved in to these activists. Here is the result, from the Los Angeles Business Journal.

Comment by Janet Mercer-Grey on December 15, 2010 at 4:49pm

So now that the La Mesa City Nanny-in-chief and the little Nannett's have effectively agreed with First Lady Michele Obama that some issues are too important to leave to citizens to decide I have a few other issues that need to be addressed right away.

Alcohol must be eliminated as DUI's and public drunkenness has been a problem in the past and the police cannot be trusted to fully do their jobs in the future to rid us of this scourge.

During my walk around Christmas Nights last week I could clearly see paintings of nudes through the windows of O'Dunn's studio. Children could see these for goodness sakes. My eyes are now burning!

I have noticed that some people are leaving their holiday lights on all night long. I can feel the planet warming as a result.

Fountains Aquarium has lots of fish. Where do they buy them? A fish mill? I bought 6 fish for a dollar several years ago for my kids to feed and enjoy and learn responsibility and a couple died within a few weeks. I now believe it was from diseases brought on by of having too many fish in a tank at one time and not regularly rotating them to a tank with fresh water. We buried them in the back yard and I'm sure i could find their remains so an autopsy can be performed.


Comment by Karen Pearlman on December 15, 2010 at 12:58pm

Excellent story!


DSnews: Mortgage rates fall
By Tory Barringer
Per Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey, the 30-year fixed rate mortgage (FRM) this week averaged a rate of 4.27 percent (0.7 point), down from 4.34 percent last week. A year ago, the 30-year FRM sat at 3.41 percent.

Wall Street Journal: The education of the luxury buyer
By Sanette Tanaka
Seasoned home buyers—people who described themselves as owning a "high-end luxury home"—approach the purchasing process much differently than those venturing into the high-end market for the first time, according to an online survey conducted by in March


More Real Estate News

La Mesa Weather

Latest La Mesa Activity

A blog post by La Mesa Today was featured
52 minutes ago
A blog post by Gina Garcia was featured
3 hours ago
La Mesa Today posted a status
"Fletcher Parkway/Amaya area may have noticed police activity and helicopters. It was a domestic violence incident with suspect now detained."
20 hours ago
La Mesa Today shared their blog post on Facebook
21 hours ago
Sally Murphy shared La Mesa Today's blog post on Facebook
23 hours ago
Sally Murphy shared La Mesa Today's blog post on Facebook
23 hours ago
Elaine Arapostathis liked La Mesa Today's blog post On La Mesa: Boston's Finest
23 hours ago
Batman commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'La Mesa Politics'
"There is something worse than an Art Madrid protégé - a David Alvarez…"
Marie McLaughlin commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'La Mesa Politics'
"With Councilmen Arapostathis & Ewin giving up their Council seats, it's a little scary to…"
Mark Cavanaugh commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'La Mesa Politics'
"It is hard to imagine whoever replaces Mark win or lose could put the City in any worse shape than…"
La Mesa Today shared their blog post on Facebook
La Mesa Today posted blog posts
Batman commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'La Mesa Politics'
"I won't break my heart if Madrid loses, but if Dr. Mark loses his council seat for…"
2 blog posts by La Mesa Today were featured
Batman commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'Crime Watch'
"How did a convicted felon gang member on parole get his hands on a firearm? This entire shooting…"
Timothy F. Bryant commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'Crime Watch'
"Unfortunately, the suspect in this situation took his own life and removed himself from the Gene…"
knikki royster commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'Crime Watch'
"La Mesa is the new City Heights.... Never a dull moment"
Lisa Moore commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'Crime Watch'
"Another exciting day in La Mesa!  I was watching this with binoculars from my home in Windsor…"
Mark Cavanaugh commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'La Mesa Politics'
"Yes Art, because of you, we have $12M in grants and you also invented the internet with Al…"
Kevin G George commented on La Mesa Today's blog post 'La Mesa Politics'
"" Several of Madrid's supporters complained that they knew little about the…"

© 2014   Created by La Mesa Today.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service